Here we go again with cutting away the lock bar access in the carbon fiber scales. But I also ran into lots of problems with burrs on the blade tang, bad bearings, and more.
Rosie XL Replica Review: When Bigger Isn’t Always Better
Rosie XL Replica Review: When Bigger Isn’t Always Better
Today we’re looking at the Oz Machine Co Roosevelt 'Rosie' XL replica. This version features cryogenically treated D2 steel instead of MagnaCut and runs on ceramic ball bearings that deliver an impressively smooth, drop-shut action. The overall fit and finish are nicely executed, making this an interesting take on the popular design.
However, the XL has a fundamental issue - rather than thoughtfully scaling up the original's perfect EDC proportions, they simply enlarged everything 1:1. The result is oversized finger choils and ergonomics that might work for someone with truly massive hands but lose the "hand-melting" comfort that made the original Roosevelt legendary. What could have been an exciting larger version instead feels cartoonishly proportioned for average-sized hands. It's a missed opportunity to preserve the magic of the original while adding some extra blade length.
This video provides an educational review of a pocket knife purchased from an online marketplace. The product discussed is not affiliated with or endorsed by any established knife manufacturers. As an independent reviewer, I aim to objectively examine the quality, features, and performance of this budget-friendly option. Viewers should be aware that the origin, materials, and manufacturing processes of such products cannot be independently verified. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an endorsement or recommendation. I encourage viewers to research and make informed decisions when considering knife purchases.
Find the KPL Knife Shield here: https://amzn.to/4fmCIOm
Find the Wicked Wax knife protectant here: https://amzn.to/4c41enE
However, the XL has a fundamental issue - rather than thoughtfully scaling up the original's perfect EDC proportions, they simply enlarged everything 1:1. The result is oversized finger choils and ergonomics that might work for someone with truly massive hands but lose the "hand-melting" comfort that made the original Roosevelt legendary. What could have been an exciting larger version instead feels cartoonishly proportioned for average-sized hands. It's a missed opportunity to preserve the magic of the original while adding some extra blade length.
This video provides an educational review of a pocket knife purchased from an online marketplace. The product discussed is not affiliated with or endorsed by any established knife manufacturers. As an independent reviewer, I aim to objectively examine the quality, features, and performance of this budget-friendly option. Viewers should be aware that the origin, materials, and manufacturing processes of such products cannot be independently verified. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an endorsement or recommendation. I encourage viewers to research and make informed decisions when considering knife purchases.
Find the KPL Knife Shield here: https://amzn.to/4fmCIOm
Find the Wicked Wax knife protectant here: https://amzn.to/4c41enE
Find links to all Knives here: https://bladesonabudget.com/knives/
Free Temu $100 Coupon Bundle:
Use https://bladesonabudget.com/temu100 to get a Free 💰$100 Coupon Bundle!! (it's for real)
* Some of the links here are affiliate links and I may receive a small commission if you use them. The price is the same to you either way and you’d be really helping out a small content creator (that’s me) by using these links. Thank you! 🙂
Recent Posts
Cut Test – Petrified Fish Beluga
The Petrified Fish Beluga is a beautiful full sized knife in Bohler K110 steel (=D2). Let’s see how it holds up in our cut tests.
A Knife From Temu That Looks Like A Miller Bros T-1 Custom
This massive full titanium knife with 1/4” steel blade is designed to look like a Miller Brothers T-1 Custom. When Temu had a Black Friday special on it, I decided to check it out.
Cut Test – Miguron Moyarl
In this video we’re continuing with some basic cut tests with a few well known knives (Miguron Moyarl here) to get a baseline of how well the edge holds up in cutting different material.
Blades On A Budget supports our readers and viewers by product testing and reporting to help you find the best EDC gear, knives, and tools. We are a participant in affiliate programs, including the Amazon Services LLC Associate Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and other affiliated sites. Using these links does not raise the price you pay for these products. You are simply helping to support an American small business. 🙂